Ian,
thank your for reply.
It would interesting to know camera you are using. I find that Canon D30/60 and 10D images are a lot more noise free than Phase One. However, I must be honest and say that I do NOT like Phase One software at all. I suppose that makes me biased
My camera now is a 1Ds, before a D60. I am not sure anylonger how noisy the D60 is (I thought less than the 1ds), but regarding the 1ds I do find that Phase One DSLR produces an extremely good clean up job. Often it is more like ACR plus Moire checked plus Neatimage. My only complain is the lack of control on this process and the price with respect to desaturation that I seem to pay at times.
Images that bother me most are of course those taken under unfortunate lighting conditions, to some degree underexposed on top and of course with a higher ISO setting like 400+.
I tried one of these with SF DCPRO, P1DSLR, ACR and Canon FVU, In my opinion P1 is leading the pack, followed by a close field.
I had a quick look at GAINE, but that looks like it is producing too soft results.
The Quicktime movies help a lot but there are still important gaps. By this I mean that some start at a point that suggests they are a follow-on from a movie you should have already watched. I can't find the one that "seems" to preceed these. The Job movie is particularily poor in this regard.
Yes especially the links from the President and looking at the files from within the DEMO are very helpful to understand the application.
I've tried for weeks to figure how to obtain a high quality preview can be obtained without converting the image. It seems that it's not possible even though we know that the original CRW file (Canon) contains a high quality JPEG that could be used. Unfortunately I think that JPEG can only be got at after conversion. I'm seeing something similar on other conversion apps.
I followed the presidents suggestion, and space clicked, yes that is what I like to get. However I am wondering why the building of the fill size preview after the "conversion" takes such a long time. On my PC I almost thought that the speed is good until also there this enlarged view building, that happens every time when clicking another already converted image, in overview mode strated to slow down. Great feature, but my 6Ghz PC/Mac has not yet arrived

.
BTW: the demo doesn't have IT8 enabled and this makes it more difficult to get the WB right. With IT8 enabed and a good ICC profile for you camera it is much easier to nail the WB.
Well here my first frustration seems to be buried. Without profiles the SF 1ds conversions are somehow off, compared to P1 or ACR. I then thought of using the P1 profiles in SF, BAD idea as I realize now, since they are not at all compatible, the results were really really bad and no tweaking could repair that. I have now ordered the software to try the profiling from within SF, will see where that brings me.
Charles,
I find the quality of the raw conversion of my D1X excellent. I've been running the beta and the color with the it-8 calibration is dead on and the files seem to have less noise in the shadows than the Adobe Raw files I've been using. While I haven't timed the conversion process, it seems in line with the other converter software. No problems with the raw conversion that I can see.
It is nice to hear that you manage well, I am looking forward to that it-8 feature. However regarding the basic conversion quality, it might be in line with the others, however apart from the Chroma noise removal, a P1 special, the Canon Convertor and ACR also do a better moire removal job . I found moire with SF in buildings that Canon FVU has removed (of course not sure what else they removed).
I have difficulty getting VLT to run with Nikon raw NEF files, looks like a memory issue reading thumbnails. I was hoping that would be fixed in the final version, but the demo does it as well. I have to make sure I'm in a folder that has fewer than 15 NEF files in it. Once the files have been read once everything is fine (either by breaking the folders down into 15 file chunks or reading, forced quit restarting, reading, forced quit restarting, like they're being cached and once they're cached everything works well. With over 20,000 raw files, breaking them down into small folders to read is really not an option. If the files haven't been cached and are in a directory with more than 15 or 20 files, the application simply hangs and has to be forced quit and restarted (I'm on Mac OSX 10.2).
Thank you very much Charles for writing this, I ended in a similar funny deadlock with my 1ds files. 1st the application would hang starting, hanging in preview loading (I forgot the exact name). I solved this by reducing the set as you did. Then every time I tried to convert, the application crashed. I solved that by deleting the silverfast preferences. But next came a "Finder under glass" where I could not drag icons anylonger neither in the finder nor the VLT. I solved that by deleting some system icon cache file. Well now it seems to run again. Scary.
Once I receive the full Version with IT8, I might set up a small comparison, right now due to color issues, it does not make any sense to do that.
Mr President, you got my order today, do i really have to wait for a shipped Version in the post, (I can be patient, really).
Thanks again for replies.
Stefan