future of film scanning
PostPosted: Sun May 31, 2009 4:13 pm
The recent discontinuation of the Nikon Coolscan 5000 appears to leave only the Coolscan 9000 as a "quality" film scanner on the market, and an expensive one at that. My Minolta Dimage Scan Multi Pro is still working ok - although it seems to showing a tendency to colour shift towards blue, whatever I do with calibration - but it won't work forever, and the drivers can't be expected to remain compatible with many future generations of OS releases (in my case OS X).
As far as I can see, the only remaining players are at the ultra-high, forget about it end (Hasselblad / Imacon) or the entry level (Plustek) which I cannot imagine offers much quailty, and in any case is 35mm only (I mainly scan XPan transparencies).
I'm not convinced that flat bed scanners like the Epson V750 offer the same level of dynamic range as the Minolta or Nikon scanners (although I'd be happy to be convinced otherwise) ...
So, as a general question, is there any future for film scanning as we know it ? Is there not an opportunity here for a well known specialist in the field to produce their own brand film scanners (I know Lasersoft is a software not hardware company, but anyway...) ... or do we try to grab one of the last Coolscan 9000s (accepting they're actually not all that good) and put in the freezer until we need it ?
Or is it Game Over ?
As far as I can see, the only remaining players are at the ultra-high, forget about it end (Hasselblad / Imacon) or the entry level (Plustek) which I cannot imagine offers much quailty, and in any case is 35mm only (I mainly scan XPan transparencies).
I'm not convinced that flat bed scanners like the Epson V750 offer the same level of dynamic range as the Minolta or Nikon scanners (although I'd be happy to be convinced otherwise) ...
So, as a general question, is there any future for film scanning as we know it ? Is there not an opportunity here for a well known specialist in the field to produce their own brand film scanners (I know Lasersoft is a software not hardware company, but anyway...) ... or do we try to grab one of the last Coolscan 9000s (accepting they're actually not all that good) and put in the freezer until we need it ?
Or is it Game Over ?